Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Computerfreak101's Forums » The YuGiOh! Fanfiction Contest Topic Subscription

Forums » The YuGiOh! Fanfiction Contest » Judging - Season 6
Author Post
Computerfreak101
Topic: Judging - Season 6

Okie dokie, first round's done, and I see that most of you managed to get your fics in on time. Great job, and a very impressed kudos to those who posted fics in the first few days, well DONE. Now hopefully you all heeded my advice to read the fics as they were posted, so we don't end up getting to the last day and still having 9 people left to vote. The judging is very straightforward, you have 4 days to finish reading the fics if you haven't already and then vote for your favorite, for the one fic you think deserves to go through to the next round. As I said before, if you don't vote, you lose a vote from your tally. If this causes your vote count to dip into the negatives, you're disqualified. Since there's so MANY fics, we'll probably have to go to a tiebreaker, but we'll cross that bridge when it comes to it.

Ryou VeRua - It's a Kaiba Thing - 5

YuugisGirl - Cookies and Milk - 4

Sierra's Darkness - Out of the Loop - 3

Nemisor - Not That Bad - 2

Always a Bookworm - Fear and Hope - 2

Sunshine Biscuits - Lucky Seven - 2

Jenivi7 - Promises - 1

Full Shadow Alchemist - Maybe Next Time - 1

after.a.hard.day - Harmony in C - 1

millenniumthief - Older Brothers... - 1

SilentxMistress - Not This Way - 1

Higuchimon - Smile - 1

Yami Roojii - First Date - 1

darkrunner - Memory Lapse - 1

Cheeky-eyes - Nothing - 1

Fantasy.Maker - Stuck in Their Shadow - 1

Homosexual Guitar - Unwritten Promise - 1

Out-Of-Control-Authoress - Just Smile for Me - 1

arashi wolf Pup - Can't Help But Falling In Love - 1

Cobweb Cupcakes - Surprise - 1

Inu Kaiba - Waiting Room - 1

Comicbookfan - The Sunset - 0

Doubleplusgoodduckspeaker - Shades of Gray - 0

Unique Art - A Date? - 0

YamiYugi4ever - Visit at the Orphan - 0

YamiShiningFriendship - Prom Promise - 0

Detonate - A Ride to Remember - 0

shadowkaru15 - Icecream with a shirt and a hole - 0

Angela and MiniMix - Dragon Cave - 0

chiruri chikorate - curse of kaiba - 0

Mirabelle456 - Things Change - 0

VOTES ARE DUE JUNE 16! THANKS TO EVERYONE WHO SUBMITTED A FIC, AND GOOD LUCK!

Left to Vote:

From Ryou VeRua ~ Guys, if I made a mistake in the tallying feel free to tell me. The sheer number of contestants/fics guarantees that at least one will happen - and I feel like one already did!

#1 Jun 12th, 9:25am . Edited by Hikari Daeron, Jun 16th, 4:37pm
YamiShiningFriendship

now that i can FINALLY turn my computer off due to having kept this stupid window open so i remembered my possible votes and have narrowed it down to one, imma go vote before my back up laptop dies and that be bad because then i wouldnt have a laptop for anywhere between 1 and 4 days. *breath* anyway, i liked em all, but i think my favorite (besides my own) is Nemisor's Not that bad. Seto's reactions were priceless, and i was looking for my favorite sibling reactions to whatever mokuba and serenity were doing.

So nemisor, my vote goes to you. good job

#2 Jun 12th, 9:43am
Mirabelle456

After reading all of the fics, I've gotta say that my favourite was definitely YuugisGirl's Cookies and Milk. That was probably the cutest thing I've ever read!

#3 Jun 12th, 10:27am . Edited Jun 12th, 10:28am
chiruri chikorate

I vote for promises

#4 Jun 12th, 11:39am
Always a Bookworm

Oh, this is so hard! There are so many that I want to vote for... but I'm going to have to go with Sunshine Biscuits- Lucky Seven. It was breathtaking. Just so amazing. But I had so many favourites- this was such a hard choice!

#5 Jun 12th, 12:00pm
SilentxMistress

My vote will have to go to Full Shadow Alchemist's 'Maybe Next Time'. Good job to everyone and good luck!

#6 Jun 12th, 12:18pm
Unique Art

Wow, that was hard. I had a lot of favorites since all of the authors here are amazing. But my vote goes to Nemisor - Not That Bad. Good luck to everyone!

#7 Jun 12th, 12:38pm
Nemisor

Oh this was hard, this was really really hard, voting I mean. There are so many fics I simply love.

But I think I'll give my vote to a fic that after two times of re-reading still remained beautiful and meaningful: Always a Bookworm - Fear and Hope.

Good luck to everyone! :)

#8 Jun 12th, 12:49pm
Homosexual Guitar

I gotta say my vote goes to after.a.hard.day's Harmony in C. ^^

#9 Jun 12th, 12:52pm . Edited Jun 12th, 12:52pm
Out-Of-Control-Authoress

My vote goes to YuugisGirl and 'Cookies and Milk'. I loved em' all, but this one just kind of got stuck in my head. :)

#10 Jun 12th, 1:00pm
YamiYugi4ever

I vote for "Cookies and Milk"! It was very cute and very funny at the end ^^

#11 Jun 12th, 2:31pm
Higuchimon

I vote for Ryou VeRua - It's a Kaiba Thing.

#12 Jun 12th, 2:51pm
Angela and MiniMix

cookies for my vote

#13 Jun 12th, 4:52pm
Tootchy

My vote goes to Always a Bookworm for Fear and Hope. Loved it :D

#14 Jun 12th, 4:56pm
Detonate

I vote for Sierra's Darkness - Out of the Loop

#15 Jun 13th, 2:44am
Full Shadow Alchemist

I'd say, the best characterization was in milleniumthief's story: Older Brothers...

So, my vote goes to you. Good job!

#16 Jun 13th, 9:36am
Doubleplusgoodduckspeaker

There were so many great stories, and my vote goes to SilentxMistress' Not This Way. I loved the style! :)

#17 Jun 13th, 6:42pm
arashi wolf princess

i chose Ryou VeRua - It's a Kaiba Thing. I found the story to be very delightful and i personally enjoyed it. Its very fitting from the beginng till the very end.

#18 Jun 14th, 10:54am
deadpleaseremove

Smile by Higuchimon~! The characterizations were literally spot-on and it left such a happy/fuzzy feeling inside~ =D

#19 Jun 14th, 12:25pm
YuugisGirl

I had so many favorites... but I'm going to have to go with First Date by Yami Rooji.

#20 Jun 14th, 5:11pm
millenniumthief

There were so many great ones, (and I'm sorry I didn't find time to review most of them or thank everyone for reviewing mine...Thanks guys!) but I have to pick the one closest to my gaming heart:

I pick Ryou VeRua: It's a Kaiba Thing! Nice job!

#21 Jun 14th, 7:46pm . Edited Jun 14th, 7:46pm
Ryou VeRua

There were a lot of good ones this round, to the point that I've spent the last few days trying to choose my favourite amongst four. @.@ But I think I'll go with Sierra's Darkness (you had me at 'canoodlin' (joking, joking... it was 'period' -is brick'd-). Special mention to Sunshine, darkrunner and Higuchimon ~

Also, apologies to everyone about not reviewing yet, I got caught up in Tales of Symphonia. XD;

#22 Jun 14th, 7:52pm
after.a.hard.day

Voting for Dark Runner~ TWAS WONDERFUL.

#23 Jun 15th, 1:01am
Sierra's Darkness

I'm going to go with Sunshine Biscuits' Lucky Seven. Props to Ryou VeRua, too, for writing such a lengthy fic!

#24 Jun 15th, 3:09am
shadowkaru15

after reading through all of these wonderful fanfiction I have a hard time choose one, but I went with the sarcastic one, or the one that amde me laugh the most xD

So, my vote goes to Sierra's Darkness and her Out Of The Loop^^

Good luck everyone *already knows she is last*

#25 Jun 15th, 7:58am
Fantasy.Maker

Alright real fast before my Human Sexuality test.

Ryou VeRua - It's a Kaiba Thing

#26 Jun 15th, 10:13am
darkrunner

Normally, I'd vote for something with no votes, but we're going to have such a massive tiebraker anyway, what's another fic? Ryou's was too amazing to NOT vote for. :D

#27 Jun 15th, 7:06pm
Inu Kaiba

I'll vote for cheeky.

(whoops! almost forgot hehe)

#28 Jun 15th, 7:24pm
Jenivi7

Oh! I didn't realize I was running so low on time! thanks for the reminder Rua!

I vote for Fantasy Maker!

And thankyouthankyouthankyouthankyou Compy for making siblingshipping the first challenge. It's one of my absolute favorites and now there's soooo many good stories for it!

#29 Jun 15th, 7:26pm
Comicbookfan

I'm gonna vote for some one with no votes, so--Homosexual Guitar, 'Unwritten Promise'.

#30 Jun 15th, 9:21pm
Yami Roojii

Out-Of-Control-Authoress's 'Just Smile for Me'. X3 It was uber cute.

#31 Jun 16th, 12:28pm
Cheeky-eyes

arashi wolf Pup

#32 Jun 16th, 2:59pm
Computerfreak101

Before anyone says it, NO, Hika and I are not lazy. We are both busy, but the main reason we are both the last to vote is because as your overlords it is our DUTY to attempt to shorten the inevitable tiebreaker. *self important nod* So. Cobweb Cupcakes. My vote. You have it.

#33 Jun 16th, 3:05pm
Hikari Daeron

*waves over at Compy's post*

I have to say, Lily's was my favourite, I loved Sunshine's, and a bunch of others were short, sweet, and potential-filled. Not to mention Higuchi, Ryou, Yuugi's Girl.

SO. In favour of lessened tiebreaker, I'm voting Ama.

#34 Jun 16th, 4:33pm . Edited Jun 16th, 4:34pm
Computerfreak101

MY MINIONS, THANK YOU! YOUR HEARTS HAVE PLEASED THE METROCON GOD (who it turns out is actually Darth Vader) AND HAVE RETURNED ME SAFELY TO MY RIGHTFUL THRONE! (For pics of the harrowing experience, check out Top_Hat12 on photobucket. Sushi earings!) Now let's weed out the one and move on to the medium pairings. X3

Sunshine Biscuits - faces at the bottom of the well - 3

Always a Bookworm - Awkward - 2

Ryou VeRua - Scenario ABC - 2

Out-Of-Control-Authoress - Fool Me Once, Fool Me Twice - 2

YuugisGirl - Venus Flytrap - 2

Nemisor - Unreachable - 2

Mirabelle456 - The Kissing Card Game - 1

Cobweb Cupcakes - Breaking The Habit - 1

Detonate - Be Careful What You Wish For - 1

Doubleplusgoodduckspeaker - Change of Heart - 1

Jenivi7- Ghosts, Goths and other Anxieties - 1

Inu Kaiba - Tuesday - 1

Higuchimon - Everywhere - 1

Unique Art - Running - 1

Fantasy.Maker - Bloody Teeth and Another Missing Animal - 1

Cheeky-eyes - All Over Again - 1

millenniumthief - Summertime - 1

darkrunner - The End of Alcatraz - 1

Comicbookfan - Other Halves - 1

Full Shadow Alchemist - All We Are - 1

SilentxMistress - Sugary Wine - 1

chiruri chikorate - advice from an unlikly source - 1

arashi wolf Pup - Teardrops on My Guitar - 0

YamiYugi4ever - Let's spin the bottle! - 0

Homosexual Guitar - Wonderland - 0

YamiShiningFriendship - Carnival Games - 0

DUE JULY 4TH!

#35 Jun 30th, 7:51am . Edited by Ryou VeRua, Jul 04th, 7:45pm
Mirabelle456

Aside from Psychoshipping last season, this is the most slash fics I've read in a while... they were all written so well, and I had so much trouble weeding it down to just one... butI'm definitely gonna have to go with Detonate's Be Careful What You Wish For

Great job, Detonate, your fic was amazing.

And great job, everyone else, I might just have to start reading a bit more slash after the quality of these fics!

#36 Jun 30th, 8:00am
arashi wolf princess

It was between Mirabelle456's The Kissing Card Game or darkrunner's The End of Alcatraz out of all the others. Everyone's is great but I have to choose one so I choose. Mirabelle456's The Kissing Card Game. It is a wonderful story and couldn't stop reading.

#37 Jun 30th, 8:06am
chiruri chikorate

my vote is for cobweb cupcakes breaking the habit

#38 Jun 30th, 8:10am
Ryou VeRua

I'm walking on Sunshine ~

... I'm sorry, that was bad. XD

#39 Jun 30th, 8:26am
Homosexual Guitar

I vote for Sunshine Biscuits Faces at the bottom of the well ^^ Ryou was perfect in that.

#40 Jun 30th, 8:34am
SilentxMistress

My vote'll go to Always a Bookworm's Awkward.

#41 Jun 30th, 9:40am
YamiYugi4ever

*thinks* there were a lot that I liked, it's gonna be hard to choose only one... *keeps thinking* ok, I'll go with Unreachable from Nemisor, it was so sweet ^^

#42 Jun 30th, 9:40am
Out-Of-Control-Authoress

Comedy is something I absolutely adore. Therefore, my vote must go to RyouVeRua and Scenario ABC. Congratulations, I almost gave myself a concussion when I fell out of my chair laughing! *snickers*

#43 Jun 30th, 11:39am
Detonate

I will place my vote on Bookworm's Awkward !! I loved it ! :D

#44 Jun 30th, 12:32pm
Nemisor

I'll vote for YuugisGirl and Venus Flytrap. It was amazing! :)

#45 Jun 30th, 12:46pm
Tootchy

It was really hard for me to choose this round- everyone's fics were so good.

In the end, I chose to vote for Doubleplusgoodduckspeaker's (gosh, that's a mouthful,) 'Change of Heart'. :3

#46 Jun 30th, 1:24pm
YamiShiningFriendship

I vote for out of control authoress' "Fool me once, fool me twice"

#47 Jun 30th, 5:47pm
Comicbookfan

I say...hmm...I'll have to vote for RyouVerua's 'Scenario ABC'. Just because it was hilarious. And...there were Soul Eater references, man!

#48 Jun 30th, 8:23pm . Edited Jun 30th, 8:23pm
Higuchimon

I vote for: Sunshine Biscuits - faces at the bottom of the well

#49 Jul 01st, 12:44am
Unique Art

These were all so great! I had so many favorites, but my vote goes to Jenivi7- Ghosts, Goths and other Anxieties.

Good luck guys!

#50 Jul 01st, 4:23am


Moderator(s): Computerfreak101, Hikari Daeron, Angela and MiniMix, Yami Roojii, Familiar-Possessed - Eria, Ryou VeRua, Inu Kaiba,
Rule(s):
  1. Forums are not to be used to post stories.
  2. All discussions including language and content must be suitable for teens.
  3. The owner/moderator(s) of this forum is solely responsible for content posted within this area.
  4. All forum abuse must be reported to the moderator(s).
Members:
  1. Forum admin/moderator
  2. Fanatic (on site for more than 2 years)
  3. Fan (on site for more than a year)
  4. Regular (on site for more than 6 months)
  5. Camper (on site for more than a month)
  6. Apprentice (on site for more than a week)
  7. Newbie (on site for less than a week)

All times are GMT -8, US Pacific Time Zone.
Return to Top