This or That? --Doctor Who style - American Doctor Who Forum

Star Wars. The Doctor running around with someone who does triple leaps over his haed and slices the daleks in half with a lightsaber would just be funny.

BTW, in response to your answer to my last question, in my fic, the child Doctor is from Wales, but I did consider Scotland for a while. But the Doctor's dislike of Cardiff sort of clinched it for me.

Should the Doctor go back to work for: UNIT or Torchwood?

#51 Jul 26th 2007, 11:20pm

Even though Jack's head of Torchwood now, I think the Doctor would still be mistrustful of Torchwood. Therefore, I think he'd go back to work for UNIT. Plus, if he did, it'd be a great excuse to bring back the Brigadier!

Talking of which, which 2nd Doctor companion would be brought back first: Jamie or Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart?

#52 Jul 27th 2007, 12:28am

I love Lethbridge Stewart, but read somewhere that he wouldn't be coming back due to declling health. So it would either be someone playing his son, or perhaps his grandson. So I'd have to say Jamie.

Which Doctor kiss do you like most.

8th and Grace Kiss or 9th and Rose Kiss.

(I know very cheesy but I have to ask. hah)

#53 Jul 27th 2007, 8:16am

9th and Rose. Eight kissing Grace ws hilarious, but wasn't nearly as emotional as Ninth and Rose's kiss. Not to mention, I'm an avid 10Rose shipper, so 9Rose would have to be the next best thing.

Who should come back as a companion: Adric or Tegan? (please disregard the fact that Adric is dead)

#54 Jul 27th 2007, 11:48am

Oh, I don't know, they both seemed a little off-balance with the rest of the show, but I think Eight and Grace. And this time, it has nothing to do with my dislike for Rose. People are saying that David is the most human Doctor. But I think it's Eight, because he was so Eight! Of all the Doctors, Eight was the 'domestic Doctor' for me, and that kiss seemed much more natural than the kiss between Nine and Rose. Nine didn't seem like someone who would kiss her. I think there had to be some other way, and then there was that cheesy line beforehand, which nearly made me gag. But I didn't like Eight's kiss either, I blame that on the American influence. My country needs to stay out of the Doctor Who continuum, we keep messing it up with strange Masters, half-human nonsense and Chinese gangsters. Seriously, where did we come up with the plotline for the TV movie? But I'm getting severly off-track now.

So, laser screwdrivers or sonic screwdrivers? (If you haven't seen The Sound of Drums, don't bother with this)

#55 Jul 27th 2007, 11:50am

Sonic screwdriver. It's much more versatile than a laser screwdriver, which can only kill people in interesting ways.

Another crossover question! Yay! ^w^

The Doctor and Optimus Prime vs. the Decepticons or the Doctor and Samus Aran vs. space pirates?

#56 Jul 27th 2007, 12:34pm

Got Scots

((Wow I haven't been to my forum in a while. Sorry, guys!!))

Star Wars/Doctor Who. I love Obi-Wan!!!

Okay, in honor of the last episode:

Would you rather turn into a pig man or human dalek?

#57 Aug 06th 2007, 7:13pm

Got Scots

Ehhhhh. Ehhhh. Sory about this last post! I was reading from page one....

And I'd choose Samus Aran!!! Totally!

Alas, my question still remains: pigman or human dalek?

#58 Aug 06th 2007, 7:15pm

Meh.... I did not care for that episode or should I say episodes. I thought it one of the worse Dalek episodes ever. I am sorry, but since when do Daleks absorb themselves into humans? Never. Never ever, to do so or to even to consider it is like heresy of the first degree. Course I could say the same about Bad Wolf and Parting of the Ways as well. Oh well, I digress.

If I had to choose between being a pigman or a Dalek infused human, I'd choose being a Human Dalek. Only because of the supremecy issues.

Let me see....

oooh I have one.

Sonic Screwdriver or Sonic Laser? heh.

#59 Aug 06th 2007, 11:10pm

ack.... never mind my last question. I see it's already been asked. I feel like an idiot.

Ohh I know now.

Which villian is scarier Weeping Angels or Gelith?

#60 Aug 06th 2007, 11:14pm

Oh, God, the Weeping Angels were WAY scarier than some stupid gas people! I've never been able to look at angel statues the same way again.

Which is the better super-powerful, incredibly large Doctor Who enemy: the Beast or the Living Sun?

#61 Aug 07th 2007, 12:18am

I'll put it bluntly: I loved '42'!!!!!!! LOVE, LOVE, LOVE, LOVE, LOVE LOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVELOVE.....................

(Two hours later)

......Love, love, love, love, love, love, love, love,love, love, love, love, love, love, love,love, love, love, love, love, love, love,love, love, love, love, love, love, love,love, love, love, love, love, love, love.....

Alright, now that I've got that out of my system. (I've waited a long time to do that) Living Sun, without a doubt... When the Doctor said "I'm so scared" it sent shivers up my spine.... loved that episode!!!!!!!!

Whose the best evil Time Lord? The Master or The Rani

#62 Aug 07th 2007, 11:48am

Oh, it's probably the Master, although I am a super-Rani fan, even if she is underdeveloped. We need more Rani episodes! And 42 was interesting, but I wouldn't go so far as that many LOVES. Maybe two...or three LOVES.

Okay, should there be a 'The Ten Doctors' or an episode where the Doctor switches bodies with his companion?

#63 Aug 07th 2007, 2:12pm

Doctor and Samus Aran, if only because I know more about that.

Which quote do you like better?

"Nine hundred years of time and space and I've never been slapped by someone's mother..."

"Sideburns - I've got sideburns!"

#64 Aug 08th 2007, 12:47pm

Alright, someone was random and didn't answer the question before them, so I'll answer both.

I'd rather see a switch with the Doctor's companion, that'd be funny. Besides, I wrot a "the Ten Doctor" fic, and trust me, it gets a little full. too many people, not enought time or space to write any diolouge.

As for the better quote: "Nine hundred years of time and space and I've never been slapped by someone's mother..." the sideburns line was funny, but there were a whole lot better lines in that little seven minute tv clip.

How should the 10th Doctor regenerate into the 11th: the Master or the Daleks?

#65 Aug 08th 2007, 2:21pm

I did. I dunno how those posts got in front of me...Good Lord, how fast do you have to post so that you CAN answer the question in front of you? O___o;;

"How should the 10th Doctor regenerate into the 11th: the Master or the Daleks?"

Daleks, hands down.

Better female villain: Cassandra or Lilith?

#66 Aug 08th 2007, 4:42pm

Lilith hands down. Sorry but the bloated peice of skin doesn't inspire me to think of her as a vilian too much.

I have an excellent question to ask.

Which Historic Event should the Doctor travel to?

The Salem Witch trials or Christopher Columbus sailing in 1492

#67 Aug 09th 2007, 12:39am

I think Christopher Columbus, since we already did that whole witch thing with The Shakespeare Code. And if you do something with sailing, you can bring in Sea Devils!

Now, which makes less sense?

The Master having his trial on Skaro, or Jack Harkness being the Face of Boe?

#68 Aug 09th 2007, 9:42am

The Master being tried on Skaro. At least there is some credible evidence that Jack could be the Face of Boe. If the Master's a Time Lord, logic tells me he should be tried on his home planet.

Best way to ** Rose off: Bring back Grace Holloway and let slip that she kissed the Doctor first or bring back Susan and let slip that she's the Doctor's granddaughter?

#69 Aug 09th 2007, 11:22am

"Best way to ** Rose off: Bring back Grace Holloway and let slip that she kissed the Doctor first or bring back Susan and let slip that she's the Doctor's granddaughter?"

I wouldn't want to ** Rose off in any way, but I'd say bringing back Susan. Rose would be more furious over that than a kiss.

Better monster creator: John Lumic or Davros?

#70 Aug 09th 2007, 11:57am

Oooh lots of similarites between Davros and Lumic. Both are insane, sadistic, and demented. I am going to say Lumic.

Which Doctor lite episode was the best?

Love and Monsters or Blink

#71 Aug 09th 2007, 5:34pm

"Which Doctor lite episode was the best?

Love and Monsters or Blink?"

Love and Monsters. Haven't seen Blink yet, which sucks.

Which new series villain-race was creepier, the Gelth or the Empty Children?

#72 Aug 11th 2007, 5:13pm

Has to be the Empty Children. Those guys creeped the hell outta me, and that was before I'd seen "Blink".

A historical event you think the Doctor had a hand in: Columbus getting to America ("No, Chris, India's that way.") or helping out in the American Revolution ("Then the British are going to try this, but if you go here...")

#73 Aug 12th 2007, 2:08am

waterdragon719

Columbas getting to America hands down. There's no way he could have actually done it on his own...lol. And I could imagine The Doctor saying that...

Who was a better companion, Kamelion or Compassion the Living Tardis?

#74 Aug 12th 2007, 2:34am

Kamelion... he was so underplayed, if you ask me... I don't care if the stupid little prop was broken... they could've at least had the dang robot choose a favorite form and have that be Kamelion, only bringing the prop out when it was needed. It would've been cool if they'd had a 'good guy Master' running around the TARDIS.

#75 Aug 13th 2007, 1:46pm

oops, I forgot to ask a question... he-he... =}

Ummmm..........

In "Pete's World", as it's affectionately refered to by the Doctor, should Rose meet up with the Eighth Doctor or the Fourth Doctor?

#76 Aug 13th 2007, 2:05pm

Fourth Doctor. Love him. ^^

Who would be better to play the next companion, Catherine Zeta-Jones or Kate Winslet?

A purely hypothetical question, of course.

#77 Aug 13th 2007, 2:46pm

I dunno, that'd be a hard choice to make... I love Cathrine Zeta-Jones, but following the disaster that was Peri, I'm still not sure I've recovered from the 'non-English' companion. As long as RTD writes for the show, I think I could manage Cathrine Zeta-Jones...

Would you rather own: a TARDIS diguised as a police box, or a TARDIS with a working chamelion circut?

#78 Aug 13th 2007, 9:10pm

Ten and Rose-Eternal Love

Police box. Because that's the classic.

Which BBC America show would you rather have the TARDIS land in: Hotel Babylon or Coupling?

#79 Aug 22nd 2007, 7:39pm

Coupling.

Oh gosh that would be hilarious. I can just see the look on Steve's face when the Doctor explains his life as a Time Lord and all. Classic! Jack Davenport is so funny!

The Doctor and Rose getting stuck on a reality show:

American Idol or America's Got Talent?

#80 Aug 27th 2007, 11:07am

American idol, i'd love to see the Doctor sing "Hit me with your Rhythm Stick" again.

Should the Doctor meet up (School Reunion-style) Leela or Romana

#81 Sep 02nd 2007, 10:38pm

Should the Doctor meet up (School Reunion-style) Leela or Romana

Romana - I haven't seen any of Leela and I've only seen Romana in the Shada segment of The Five Doctors.

New Series 3 or the Multiple Doctor stories

#82 Sep 03rd 2007, 12:36am

What do you mean New Series Three? Like, a do-over? Because I think, if you consider the travesty that was Series Two, it did fine! So I'll have to go with the multiple Doctors story. I did a story like that, too. With companions,too.

Which would make Rose sadder:

Her and Ten meeting up with the Third Doctor, or the Tenth Doctor telling her all about how amazing his past companions were (for example *pulls out list*, Fitz, Romana ((both of her)), Leela, so on, so forth)

#83 Oct 12th 2007, 9:41pm

How would Rose and Ten hooking up with Three make Rose sad?

#84 Oct 16th 2007, 9:32am

Fusionmix

Ten pulling out the list and reading everybody off. She threw such a fit over Sarah-Jane, it would be plain hilarious. And we'd get to see if she slaps like her mom ^_^

Hmmm...el question. Must think of one...ooh!

Which would you rather have to read (yes, I'm horrible, and no, you can't say neither):

A smutty One/Rose, OR a smutty Jackie/Nine

-runs away to cleanse mind of bad images-

#85 Oct 28th 2007, 5:50pm

What do you mean New Series Three?

I meant the third new series, which doesn't mean the original series three from the William Hartnell era, but the medicore third series from David Tennant.

And if I had to choose from the above decision, it would be a smutty Jackie/Doctor. For some reason, I could see that happening more than a One/Rose.

Professor Yana or Mr. Saxon?

#86 Oct 30th 2007, 11:22pm

Mallorysgirl

Mr Saxon everytime:) He just crazy!!!

Ok how about either nine or ten doing the masters dance to the scissor sisters 'i can't decide'?

#87 Nov 01st 2007, 2:50pm

I was hoping that you'd chose Professor Yana, due to being better acted and having a better backstory. Still everyone has their own opinions.

I'd say the Tenth Doctor, since he seems more like the dancing type (but then again, the Ninth Doctor "danced" in The Doctor Dances).

#88 Nov 01st 2007, 11:16pm

Fusionmix

Since the previous poster forgot to ask a question, I will...hmm...

Were there to be a Doctor-Meets-Previous-Self episode (aside from Time Crash), would you want Eight or Nine to make a reappearance?

#89 Nov 02nd 2007, 2:33pm

I'd say that I'd want Eight to be the one. We only get him through the movie and the audio plays and he's a very good incarnation that doesn't get much love.

Which episode set in the Swingin' 60s would you want: Ten meeting up with The Beatles or finding an alien intelligence involved in the Vietnam War?

#90 Nov 02nd 2007, 3:54pm

Which episode set in the Swingin' 60s would you want: Ten meeting up with The Beatles or finding an alien intelligence involved in the Vietnam War?

I'd say the Doctor meeting the Beatles, because I like them and it would be a nice change from the normal alien invasion.

If Paul McGann was interested in returning to the television series of Doctor Who (not counting the Audios), would you give him a special episode or a series?

#91 Nov 03rd 2007, 1:55am

Stand-alone series! Oh! I know! Time War!!!! A Time War series.... awesome!

if the doctor got himself mixed up with a novel character, would it be: Harry Potter or Eragon.

ex. "Hello, I'm Eragon!" Meet my Dragon Sahpira."

"I'm not your dragon, moron..."

#92 Nov 16th 2007, 8:57pm

Harry Potter, since I know more on him, plus it would be great to see the Doctor as a teacher of Harry's during his time at Hogwarts.

Steven Moffat or Russell T Davis?

#93 Nov 16th 2007, 10:25pm

Seven moffat, hands down. RTD's writing only started getting really good in series 3. Don't get me wrong, i like a lot of his stories, they're just not as good as some others.

old TARDIS interior or new TARDIS interior?

#94 Nov 17th 2007, 12:24pm

waterdragon719

Old Tardis was cleaner and smaller, and it looked a whole lot more spacy than new tardis...but new tardis is bigger :)

Which sounds like a better day out, Ten at a New years party (after drinking too much banana daiquiri) or Five cheering at the cricket (foam fingers, beer and all)...

#95 Nov 17th 2007, 8:10pm