| Author |
Post |
 |
Avindara NirveneTopic: xJames Potter I
Lily's husband, Harry's daddy, Ginny's father-in-law, James/Albus/Lily's grandpa, Sirius/Remus/Peter's best friend, victim of Voldemort. | #1 Nov 24th 2007, 8:35pm . Edited May 06th 2008, 8:06am | |
|
 |
Avindara Nirvenethere you go, Sharkie. :)Obviously, James was born while his parents were quite a bit older - so he was doted upon and had a big ego when he was in Hogwarts, where he met Lily. Hm.. do you guys think it was love at first sight (for James) or did the crush start later on? (it was there by fifth year, that's for sure) |
 |
Cuban Sombrero GalIt took a while to develop, that's my opinion. Because sorry, but I don't see the whole "OMG, I'm in love with that chick," kind of thing going on with James, especially not when you consider their first meeting. I think he saw her as cute as first, and then slowly he started to realise it as something more.| #3 Nov 26th 2007, 11:20pm | |
|
 |
Avindara NirveneLolyeah. I imagine him and Sirius as like Fred and George.Not intentionally, I just noticed :) and they're fairly popular (except even more harsh than Gred and Forge, I mean hanging Sniv-uhm, Severus?) |
 |
Cuban Sombrero GalActually, in my eyes, James and Sirius are nothing like Fred and George. James and Sirius, as much as it pains me to say this, are vindictive little bastards. They prank people as a way of feeling good about themselves. Sirius pranks just to hide his emotions and get back at his family. They both find happiness in other's misfortunes. Fred and George, on the other hand, prank for the fun of it, so that their friends can laugh during dark times. See the difference?| #5 Nov 27th 2007, 11:08pm | |
|
 |
Avindara NirveneYes. But I still can't get rid of the image.James and Sirius are rather evil, are they? -hmph. -gets mad at them- |
 |
A Shade of GreyI like the post-Lily James, because I've always imagined that she took away the vindictiveness in him. I mean, if she was willing to go out with him, he couldn't be too bad as a seventh-year, could he? He probably was like a Fred or a George once the two started to date.But, as much as I love Sirius, I can't imagine him ever growing out of that nice-to-his-loved-ones-and-cruel-to-everyone-else stage. He's only lovable to the people who care about him. |
 |
Cuban Sombrero Gal*nods along with Grey*That's exactly right. |
 |
Avindara NirveneI think the James&co in the fifth movie (Snape's Worst Memory) look wayy too young to be fifteen.James was obviously spoiled by elder parents who doted upon him frequently and showered him with praise. That's how he turned out on the first day of school (and beyond) Lily flattened his fathead :) |
 |
Avindara NirveneSee Cuba's James Sketch. It's one of the only non-Lily James fics around! :)we need to see him out of lily. | #10 Dec 27th 2007, 6:14am | |
|
 |
A Shade of GreyYeah, his entire character seems shaped by her; it's very hard to separate the two.How early do you think he fell in love with her, though? I've always thought very early on, like the end of first year or the beginning of second, but that's just me. | #11 Dec 27th 2007, 12:47pm | |
|
 |
Avindara NirveneYeah. Isn't there some sort of quote going on about, "If you want people to like you, just be yourself." but then again, he was a total bighead, so I guess Lily coming along was good (for deflating his head, but poor Sevv!) | #12 Jan 03rd 2008, 5:21am | |
|
 |
Lexie-HI think love was possibly a slow, steady progression and he didn't realise until he woke up one morning and thought "bloody h.ell". That said, I don't think he had the revelation until 7th year-ish, because he was just too immature, before. James is the personification of a conceited teenage male (which in no way means he's a bad person). Empathy just isn't in his vocabulary, unless it's in regard to his friends, and I also think he's bright enough to see that Lily's more vulnerable than she makes out (see my bit about Lily if that doesn't make any sense). I think she really intrigues him, because she does hide herself a bit, and he genuinely does want to get to know her. He makes an effort when given the opportunity (7th year), because he strikes me as someone who is quite opportunistic, too. Which is what would make him a great Quidditch player, amongst other things. | #13 Jan 07th 2008, 8:55pm | |
|
 |
Cuban Sombrero GalI think the real James lies somewhere between Lexie's opinion and mine. Like she said, he is, for the most part, your typical conceited teenage boy. However, I still see him as a little vindictive - mostly towards the Slytherins, who did nothing to him (although I can understand his grudge against Snape). He's not evil, but he's not the definition of pure ... he's a typical teenage boy who's only real wrong is to abuse the power he has amongst his admirers and friends.| #14 Jan 20th 2008, 12:00am | |
|
 |
Lexie-HOh, he's absolutely vindictive, I agree. But everyone can be vindictive, sometimes. I don't think that makes him a bad person, although perhaps a little misguided. I think he wouldn't be so vindictive except that Sirius would support him, and his friend's approval somehow makes some really callous things acceptable.| #15 Feb 09th 2008, 6:56pm | |
|
 |
Cuban Sombrero GalI think that a lot of James' prejudices against the Slytherins came from his parents. Some of my ideas are canon and some are a bit of my own, but basically: James parents were both involved with Aurors and anti Dark Arts forces at the Ministry, and James, being an only child with parents who were so much older, spent a lot of time there and picked up quite a few ideas. His ideas were pushed even further by Sirius, because like Lexie said, his best friend supported him and would have done anything to get back at his family.| #16 Feb 09th 2008, 7:44pm | |
|
 |
NickyFox13I think James and Lily were somewhat friendly during first year, but broke away when James turned thirteen as he hit puberty and began to lust over girls and hung out more with Peter, Remus and Sirius.| #17 Feb 11th 2008, 5:05pm | |
|
 |
Cuban Sombrero GalNah, they hated each other straight away in canon - remember the scene on the train when James and Sirius were mean to Snape.| #18 Feb 11th 2008, 10:03pm | |
|
 |
Avindara Nirvene*agreed* I wonder when James starting crushing on Lily, though.| #19 Feb 12th 2008, 3:01am | |
|
 |
KaryInTheSkyI totally agree with Cuba and Lexie. James’ prejudices come from his family and were pushed by Sirius. He had a natural dislike towards Slytherins from the beginning. And Lily and James both hated each other from the start. I imagine James and Sirius picking on her for fun when they were little...but no idea when James started to like her. Any suggestions? | #20 Feb 12th 2008, 11:45am | |
|
 |
LoganAlpha30Beats me, perhaps he did something one year and Lily or somebody else actually got hurt, he mayve have finally felt some responsibility for his actions, or it got blamed on someone else, or he saw Sirius and the others doing something that he no longer agreed with, basically saw what his actions were doing to others and felt bad. LIly probably stood up to him a lot so that might have been where is started, the one that he couldn't stand to be around became the one that he couldn't stand to be apart from. THough I still find it hard to fathom that they got together given how bad he and Sirius were to people. I've often wondered now what James and Sirius and the others would have thought had they known what Snape had to give up and why and how he was working for Dumbledore and the order. I'll go now........................ | #21 Feb 12th 2008, 12:37pm | |
|
 |
Avindara NirveneI think that would be when Lily started liking him. Because when he liked her (or lusted after her, anyway) he was still a total jerk ;PI don't think James knew before he died/and Sirius was given the same explanation as Harry was from Dumbledore ;P otherwise he wouldnt' be so bitter. And Remus doesn't know either - or he's a very good actor in Half-Blood Prince. I think the first xD | #22 Feb 13th 2008, 1:49am | |
|
 |
LoganAlpha30I don't think that Sirius ever would have forgiven or made up with Snape, but I do think that Lupin would have had he known. As for James he does kind of seem to do a 180 before Lily even seems interested in him. I'll go now..................| #23 Feb 13th 2008, 10:40am | |
|
 |
Avindara NirveneI think Remus never knew after HBP. perhaps he forgave-ish him before Dumbledore died, but as hard as I wish he did, I think he never knew that Snape was truly for Harry's side. Harry himself found out shortly after/during Lupin's death...| #24 Feb 14th 2008, 5:57am | |
|
 |
Avindara Nirvenethis is utter brilliance of lilyxjames: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2987633/1/Cameo_images| #25 Mar 13th 2008, 8:09am | |
|
 |
NickyFox13"Cameo Images" by Procrastinator-starting-2morrow is an AMAZING lilyXjames writer. Nah, they hated each other straight away in canon - remember the scene on the train when James and Sirius were mean to Snape. Forgot about that scene...thanks for reminding me! :D | #26 Jul 03rd 2008, 10:48pm | |
|
 |
thelightningstrikeI think that Lily and James are meant to be, but I do love a good old angsty SiriusxLily. Does anyone else? | #27 Dec 23rd 2008, 12:11pm | |
|
 |
albfrankI highly doubt it was ‘love at first sight’. James Potter was eleven years old when he met Lily Evans. He was very bigheaded, very young, and spoiled. I think James was far too busy loving himself then to begin loving Lily - who was just a freckly girl in Gryffindor. Plus, James was too busy to think about girls what with founding the Marauders, becoming an infamous prankster, forging friendships, and helping Moony with his furry little problem. (Though James probably had many little crushes before Lily.) I think his big crush on her initially started a few years after he met Lily - around third year, or fourth. | #28 Feb 15th 2009, 9:04pm . Edited Feb 15th 2009, 9:47pm | |
|
 |
albfrankI agree with Cuban Sumbrero Gal. Plus, being a Gryffindor there is a natural prejudice against Slytherins and vise-a-versa. But there was a good reason to hate Slytherins in that time. Voldemort was rising to power, becoming more dangerous every day, and the Slytherins were obvious supporters of him. Especially Snape. I think James viewed the Slytherins as the bad guys, and Gryffindors as the good guys. He didn't really see the Slytherins as people. He saw them as rivals and targets to harass, because they deserved it. | #29 Feb 15th 2009, 9:32pm . Edited Feb 15th 2009, 9:46pm | |
|
 |
JokegirlBefore seveth year: He's a spolied brat who thinks he can get what he wants just because he said so. While he was a brillant friend he was a malichous enemy that saw to it that his enamies were miserable just to make himself feel better. However post seventh year, not sure why, I think he realised that no one can be pure evil and raislized that nobody deserved to be treated the way he treated Snape. In other words he grew up and took his head out of his butt. | #30 Aug 15th 2009, 9:33pm | |
|
 |
NymmaI'm not so sure James really changed to be honest. As revealed by Sirius in OOTP, James still bullied Snape in seventh year. behind Lily's back, when she wasn't watching. So while he improved a bit his ways, and wasn't as arrogant as before he still did continue his bullying...should he have truly realized what an awful thing he was doing he would have apologized to all his tagrets and stopped acting that way. But he didn't. Anyway, the way I see it: James was a loyal and good friend. He would do anything for them. However, anyone else that didn't fit into his social circle wasn't worth his consideration. He bullied people who hadn't done a thing to him. Just because they were in Slytherin or came from a dark family or liked Dark Arts. And let's face it: Dark Arts isn't = Death Eaters. Harry used the cruciatus curse twice, plus Sectumsempra, yet no one held it against him. Just because you have an academic interest into Dark Arts dose not mean you are evil. After all, it all depends on the way you use it. Using Sectumsempra on a person=awful. However, using Sectumsempra to cut off the inferi's hand who is currently trying to strangle you? A very good and useful thing to do. Point being, James saw everything in black and white. Not to mention, his reason for bullying Snape was: "Because he exists" and for the fun of it. That does not seem as if James is trying to do a noble thing, he's only amusing himself when bored. | #31 Dec 23rd 2009, 5:25pm | |
|
|