Help
Home Just In Communities Forums Beta Readers Dictionary Search
Hikari-and-Yami's Forums » Best Puzzleshipping Story Contest Topic Subscription

Forums » Best Puzzleshipping Story Contest » Judges
Author Post
Hikari-and-Yami
Topic: Judges

So, this is where, if you're interested in becoming a judge, you let me know. There are no special qualifications that you have to meet to become a judge. All you need is to have a love for Puzzleshipping and be willing to read all of the nominees that we are provided. You must be open-minded to all possible stories including Yaoi, Incest, MPreg, or anything else. JUDGES MUST BE UNBIASED IN THEIR DECISIONS!

So, let me know asap.

#1 Feb 18th, 1:33pm . Edited Feb 18th, 2:19pm
shadowrealm818

Hi Hikari-and-Yami,

I would like to become one of the judges for your forum. Let me know if you would still like anyone.

Thanks,

shadowrealm818

#2 Feb 18th, 4:12pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Yes, of course! Welcome to the judging panel! Just in case you are unaware, a judge can nominate a story as well under the nominees thread. I will gather the entire judging panel at the end of the month to make our decisions.

Welcome aboard!

#3 Feb 18th, 4:22pm
MangaReader322

*jumps up-and-down* YEEEEK!!ME ME ME! I would looooove it sooooo much if I could be ajudge! I am totaly un-biased! *smiles* Being a judge would be simply FABULOUS! (lol) Just send me a message if you choose me to be a one!

I love Puzzleshipping, and I am willing to read whatever is available. I am not picky, I read anything! Especially Yaoi between RyouXbakura and JoeyXseto and YUGIXATEM!!! Yay! Please notify me ASAP if you choose me as a judge.

Thank you so much!- Cassie (MangaReader18)

#4 Feb 18th, 4:33pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Welcome aboard Cassie!

And welcome to the judging panel. As I'm sure you've already read, I will bring the judging panel into session at the end of the month. After we read all the nominees, then you can cast your vote! I'll let you know deadlines and all that once I've figured it all out. As a judge you can still nominate your favorite Puzzleshipping story under the nominees thread. There is no rule that you cannot vote for the story you choose in the beginning. This is an opportunity for both readers and judges to explore the many different Puzzleshipping stories that fanfiction has to offer. After reading all of the nominees at the end of the month, if you decide that the story you nominated is still your favorite then by all means vote for it but hopefully this will give people the chance to find new stories that people noiminate that eventually become their new favorites!

Like I said, I'll let you know all the details soon! Once you find your favorite story, feel free to nominate it under the nominees section.

Glad to have you on the panel!

#5 Feb 18th, 4:40pm
BlackCatTrain

I would love to be a judge! I'm very open minded to anything someone writes no matter what it is. It's my absolute favorite pairing after all! X3. Thanks so much!

~Train X3~

#6 Feb 18th, 5:03pm
BlackCatTrain

I would love to be a judge! I'm very open minded to anything someone writes no matter what it is. It's my absolute favorite pairing after all! X3. Thanks so much!

~Train X3~

#7 Feb 18th, 5:04pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Welcome BlackCatTrain to the judging panel!

Like I stated above I'll let all the judges know the deadlines and such once I've figured it all out. As a judge you are also allowed to nominate your favorite story under the nominees section of this forum. Glad to have you on board!

#8 Feb 18th, 5:12pm
Natoya

Hi there! I'd like to become a judge too, if you still need people. ^-^

#9 Feb 18th, 5:19pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Of course! Welcome to the judging panel!

As a judge you can still choose your favorite story to nominate under the nominees section of this forum. At the end of the month, I'll gather the judging panel so that we can read, decide, and vote.

All deadlines and such will be messaged to the judges so I'll let you know everything once I do.

Glad to have you on board!

#10 Feb 18th, 5:24pm
YkCandy

Sure, I don't mind being a judge. I'm open minded to all sorts of things. I usually only read M/MA-rated fanfiction, though, for numerous reasons.

#11 Feb 18th, 5:29pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Are you willing to read other rated fics though such as T or K+?

#12 Feb 18th, 5:34pm
YkCandy

Yes, although I'll be honest in saying I am probably better at judging stories that are M+. The stories I nominate will no doubt be M rated, although there are two or three I have which are rated less than that, which I've found good.

#13 Feb 18th, 5:49pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Alright. As long as you're willing to judge any nominees we receive that are under M fairly then WELCOME ABOARD! :) Glad to have you! As I'm sure you've read, I will call the judging panel into session at the end of the month. I will message judges about deadlines and such as soon as I figure it all out.

As a judge you can still nominate your favorite story under the nominees section of this forum. Can't wait to see your nominee!

Welcome once again!

#14 Feb 18th, 5:57pm
YkCandy

That's fine by me. I guess I better re-read some of my favourites/and or scan them and see if I can nominate one. Thank you. ( ^ ^ )~

#15 Feb 18th, 6:25pm
Jisa

Yes! This is great! I love this idea! Can I be a judge?? *jumps up and down* Please? I'm always looking for more puzzleshipping stories to read. I'll read any kind of story. XD

#16 Feb 18th, 6:44pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Great! Glad to have you on board!

I'll be sure to send you all the details about deadlines and such once I've figured it all out. As a judge, you can still nominate your favorite story under the nominees section of this forum.

Welcome to the judging panel!

#17 Feb 18th, 6:52pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Just so everyone is aware, I posted deadlines on a separate thread. Make sure you take a look at it, both Judges and readers.

#18 Feb 18th, 10:09pm
tavia454

I would like to be a judge if you still have an opening available. Let me know! Thanks, Nik

#19 Feb 19th, 5:29pm
tavia454

And since I'm such an idiot, I forgot to ask if we could vote for fics that are on other sites (such as AFF or the other one - I forget the name...). Let me know. Thanks! Later

#20 Feb 19th, 5:31pm
YuugisGirl

Are judging positions still open? *looks extremely hopeful* If they are I would LOVE to be one! I'm in the middle of a Yugioh writing contest myself and the pairings change every round. I miss my boys! *hugs Yami and Yugi* I'm open to reading everything as long as it's tastefully done! If I can be a judge please let me know!

Thanks,

YG

#21 Feb 19th, 5:37pm
YkCandy

I was going to ask the same thing as Tavia, actually. Considering there are two particularly amazing fanfiction on MediaMiner that I'd definitely nominate.

#22 Feb 19th, 5:52pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Welcome tavia454 and YG to the judging panel! Glad to have you both on board. As I'm sure you both are aware, you can also nominate a story under the nominees section of this thread.

And great question! I didn't even think about other websites. But why not? The point is to find the Best Puzzleshipping Story so other websites (such as AFF or Mediaminer) are welcomed as well. Just make sure that if its not from this site, you post the name of the story, the author, and what website you got it from. That way when I post the nominees, I can put links for the Judges so that it's easier to find.

There is only one Judge spot left so if you're interested, let me know asap!

#23 Feb 19th, 6:20pm
iSparrow

If that judge spot hasn't been taken yet, I'd definitely be interested in requesting to fill it. :)

Okay, so, hi. I'm iSparrow, but everyone calls me Lady or Megan. I'm a puzzleshipping freak but I try not to let it show in daily life because I'd probably scare people off. I mostly love writing stories, but I look for any excuse I can to read others' - so I'm always on the look-out for decent fics to read and review.

I'm a little picky on what I personally write but I try to not let that get in the way of what I necessarily read. If nominated, I would be fine with reading stories containing what's considered to be sore subjects with some (yaoi, incest, etc)...

Oh, and the whole 'unbiased' thing. Well, what comes first to me is the writing. It always has and it hopefully always will.

This sounds like a neat opportunity to snag, so if it's possible, I hope I can take it. Cheers!

#24 Feb 20th, 8:28pm
Hikari-and-Yami
And it looks like we have all are Judges now! Welcome ISparrow! Glad to have you on the panel. As I'm sure you're aware you can also nominate a story under the nominees section of this thread. Nominees close tomorrow night so I'll make sure to post an official list with links and whatnot for the Judges the following day. And I completely agree with you, its all about the writing. Thanks for your interest :) Talk to you all soon!
#25 Feb 21st, 11:06am
Hikari-and-Yami

If you still want to be a Judge but there are no more spaces then still let me know by posting on here. That way, if I decide to rise the number of Judges needed, or if one of the current Judges resign, then I know who's interested. Thanks guys!

#26 Feb 21st, 12:37pm . Edited Feb 21st, 12:41pm
icefox26

I would LOVE to become a judge i read all kinds of stories and i love puzzleshipping not to mention puppyshipping anyway i would like to become a judge in this contest please and thankyou

#27 Feb 24th, 3:36pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Thanks for the interest! Glad to hear from you, icefox26! So, the February nominees list just closed and the current Judges are off for the next two weeks reading them and voting. Right now, I have ten (including myself). On the deadline of the voting, I'm going to see if ten Judges are going to make a sufficient number or not. So, I'll let you know as soon as that deadline, which is March 8th at midnight, if we in need for some extra Judges! Talk to you soon! Thanks again!

#28 Feb 24th, 6:13pm
Hikari-and-Yami

VOTES FOR FEBRUARY 2009 DUE MARCH 8TH

VOTES RECEIVED:

tavia454

MangaReader18

Natoya

iSparrow

Hikari-and-Yami

YuugisGirl

Jisa

LEFT TO VOTE:

shadowrealm818 ~ No entry

BlackCatTrain ~ No entry

YkCandy ~ No entry

(EDIT)

Thanks to all that participated and to those who couldn't get their votes in on time or resigned their spots on the Judging Panel, thank you for the effort, anyways! Please feel free to browse around the rest of the forum and/or nominate your favorite stories! Your time and effort is appreciated!

#29 Mar 01st, 12:39pm . Edited Mar 09th, 6:36am
CAYMovedOn

Oh yes, Yuri, if you're short a judge let me know! I totally thought I already asked to be one =O oh well, just let me know please if you're in need of a few more ^_^

#30 Mar 07th, 11:55am
Hikari-and-Yami

So Larka and icefox, are you both still interested in become Judges?

#31 Mar 09th, 6:33am
icefox26
yes definitly still intrested in tha judge spot hopefully ill get it and read lots of good stories!!! ;-)
#32 Mar 10th, 6:37pm
CAYMovedOn

Sure am ;)

#33 Mar 10th, 6:39pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Then I welcome both of you to the Judging Panel! Lady or I will post the final list of nominees when the deadline comes. :)

#34 Mar 10th, 6:42pm
CAYMovedOn

-dances- Wh00t! Well, that's exciting! :D

#35 Mar 10th, 6:45pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Judges, the nominees are now up and you can vote in the new poll that iSparrow put up. Remember to read all the nominees before you vote. iSparrow will let me know the winner via email when the month is out which I will post April 1st. Besides from that, happy voting! Remember Judges only. (Two votes, remember)! :)

#36 Mar 16th, 4:48am
Hikari-and-Yami

VOTES FOR MARCH 2009 DUE MARCH 31ST

VOTES RECEIVED

Jisa

Hikari-and-Yami

MangaReader18

tavia454

Natoya

Yuugisgirl

icefox26

CrazyAboutYugi

iSparrow

LEFT TO VOTE

#37 Mar 26th, 12:16pm . Edited Apr 18th, 11:57am
Hikari-and-Yami

VOTES FOR APRIL 2009 DUE APRIL 30TH

VOTES RECEIVED

Jisa

MangaReader18

tavia454

icefox26

Natoya

iSparrow

Hikari-and-Yami

LEFT TO VOTE

Yuugisgirl

CrazyAboutYugi

#38 Apr 18th, 12:00pm . Edited Apr 30th, 5:45pm
AlwaysYourAibou

/holds hand up innocently/ I would like to become a judge. There are a lot of puzzleshipping stories out there that deserve to be nominated. I would like to help in that so certain authors can be appreciated for all their hard work!

#39 Aug 04th, 6:57pm
Hikari-and-Yami

Hey guys! Hmm, this thread has become sort of like a dead zone since everything's always talked about in the chatroom, but regardless, I'd like to publish the new Judge list. There are now ten Judges, which means all spots are filled.

BPS Judges (Alphabetical Order)

1. AlwaysYourAibou

2. Asteroid-B

3. Hikari-and-Yami

4. MangaReader322

5. Natoya

6. Red Dragon of Egypt

7. Roweena5000

8. Shamise

9. tavia454

10. Valkyria Raven

Thanks guys!

#40 Aug 04th, 10:02pm . Edited Nov 02nd, 6:37pm
Asteroid B-612

*Volunteers!* If there's ever a shortage of judges in the future, or a back-up is needed, I'd be more than happy to help out.

#41 Sep 02nd, 4:51pm
Roweena5000

*muses* I have no idea why I haven't done this before... Well I'm doing it now! Should you need a judge in the future I'm all yours.

#42 Sep 12th, 7:13am
Hikari-and-Yami

Well, Reena and Asteroid, there are two opens spots!! Still interested??

#43 Oct 04th, 6:19pm
Roweena5000

Yes, I'm still up for it. ^^

#44 Oct 04th, 6:22pm
Asteroid B-612

Yus! (^^)/

#45 Oct 06th, 11:18am
s2Teennovelist

Hey Yuri,

In case you didn't get my last nomination, I'd love to be a judge, since i know a ton of these stories are awesome I'd be more than willing to read them all and be a fair judge, i'm good and judging literature and giving it a good analysis whether i like it or not, plus i'm pretty open with anything. Just let me know when deadlines are and where i go to cast my vote, andf I'd be more than happy to join, I've already nominated a story for the November 2009 nomination. :)

#46 Nov 09th, 12:33pm

Moderator(s): Hikari-and-Yami, iSparrow,
Rule(s):
  1. Forums are not to be used to post stories.
  2. All discussions including language and content must be suitable for teens.
  3. The owner/moderator(s) of this forum is solely responsible for content posted within this area.
  4. All forum abuse must be reported to the moderator(s).
Members:
  1. Forum admin/moderator
  2. Fanatic (on site for more than 2 years)
  3. Fan (on site for more than a year)
  4. Regular (on site for more than 6 months)
  5. Camper (on site for more than a month)
  6. Apprentice (on site for more than a week)
  7. Newbie (on site for less than a week)

All times are GMT -8, US Pacific Time Zone.
Return to Top