 |
KizmetIf it were simply an action/adventure movie, I would have said it was a pleasant waste of time. The CGI is sufficient to make the ki attacks look good in live action, the fight scenes are entertaining, Piccolo doesn't look like Piccolo but he doesn't look completely ridiculous as a live action villian either. The plot is thin, but it moves along quickly and there are good moments. As an adaptation of "Dragon Ball", it has some very serious issues. Mostly characterization, Muten Roshi basically made it through the adaptation intact, he's still a slightly weird, perverted guy, middle-aged instead of old, but nothing worth getting worked up about. Goku, Yamcha and Bulma have simply been written with the wrong characters in mind. American stereotypes, not anything close to what they should be. Son Goku is supposed to be naive, confident, open-hearted, powerful and did I mention naive? He is not a cross between Clark Kent and Peter Parker. He does not worry about talking to girls or fitting in at high school. Yes, he's different from everyone else, it never crosses his mind to care. He has more trouble differentiating girls and boys than he has talking to either sex. Because of his cheerful, open deminor he makes friends everywhere he goes, he's not a high school outcast who has trouble with bullies. Goku is not meek, especially not in Dragon Ball, he wouldn't put up with bullies. Bulma and Yamcha are not hardened merecinaries. In the movie Yamcha is all about money, Bulma is all about fame. There's no trace of the boy who gets terrified at the sight of girls and wants a wish to make it better or the girl who built the Dragon Ball radar on a lark so she could wish for a ultra cute boyfriend (or possibly a life-time supply of strawberries). The good-guy half of the story is roughly based on the first Dragon Ball hunt. Their obstacles include a fight against a shapeshifter and a mountain of fire. Bulma and Goku meet Roshi and Yamcha through the quest. But the quest and teaming up is Goku's plan rather than Bulma's. The shapeshifter is Mao using some sort of device to disguise herself as Chichi, not Oolong. The mountain of fire is a volcano, and Goku deals with the lava by using the dead bodies of Piccolo's hench-monsters as stepping stones rather than having it be something silly like Frying-Pan Mountain. The bad-guy half of the quest is Piccolo Sr. trying to get his wish, only he's not old so he just want world domination. And they made Goku's Oozaru-form Piccolo's henchmen from when he last tried to conquer the Earth. In addition to completely mis-interpreting pretty much every character, the script-writers seem to think Oozaru is a proper name, rather than a description of the Saiyans' giant monkey form. The movie all comes down to Goku, due to his good and loving upbringing by Grandpa Gohan, defeating the evil of the Oozaru within him. Having Goku spend most the movie thinking of Oozaru as some sort of enemy that he has to fight only to have him learn at the last moment that he is Oozaru is a nice plot twist, it's totally wrong for Dragon Ball, but if the movie weren't based on anything it's a well set-up plot twist, the kind I enjoy seeing in a story. It's not Dragon Ball by any stretch of the imagination. The script writers Americanized the hell out of most of the characters, probably to make them more appealing to a 'mainstream' audience. Then they turned around and threw in enough elements from cannon to turn off a mainstream audience, ex: the wise old mentor being a perv. So I think it will probably fail with both Fans and people unfamiliar with the source material. Still the movie moves along at a rapid clip, you never get bored, the effects look okay, there are good moments, the characters have personality (even if they're the wrong personalities), except for Goku the character designs look okay, and even with Goku the scene with him trying and failing to control his hair with hair-gel made me laugh. It's not painful to watch... as long as you don't think about what it's supposed to be. |
 |
Rachel CabbitIt wasn't Dragonball, but it wasn't bad either. I liked how they kept little things in though. There were some apartment complexes named after Mount Paozu, Roshi's house was still on some sort of island and Bulma told Yamcha she liked "Bad Men" XD I hope for a sequel only so that they can correct the Oozaru mistake, get to the Saiyan goodness and hopefully have some Bulma x Vegeta moments. The film did pretty well, so there will probably be a sequel. Whether it goes far enough to get into the realm of Z is doubtful though. Though Piccolo was pretty awesome though. | #12 Nov 28th 2009, 7:16am | |
|